Warning: Spoilers. A link to a synopsis of this book is at the end
I first read this book (then entitled Wintle’s Wonders) as a child in the 60s. As the author intended, I identified with Rachel, the lonely, misunderstood protagonist, who eventually has her happy ending when her acting talents are recognised at the expense of her spoilt and conceited cousin Dulcie.
Re-reading it as an adult is a far more chilling experience.
Rachel’s Aunt Cora (Mrs Wintle) is a bully. Her bullying of Rachel is overt – constant criticism of her looks, her personality (described as “spiteful and jealous”), her insistence that despite a lack of interest and talent Rachel has to be trained as a Little Wonder and dance in pantomimes and musical comedy.
As with many bullies, few people are prepared to stand up to her. Her staff at the dancing school simply accept that she will be the person making the decisions, while her husband Tom avoids confrontation and keeps out the way. When Pursey (the nanny figure) and Mrs Storm (the children’s teacher) do actually make a stand for Rachel, neither has any skills with which to engage her; both go straight to offering their resignation. The only person to stand up to her verbally (and actually come off best) is 11 year old Hilary, Rachel’s adopted sister.
But far more damaging than her overt bullying of Rachel, is Mrs Wintle’s bullying of her daughter Dulcie. Rachel spends little time with her aunt and is surrounded by supportive adults – Mrs Storm, Pursey and her Uncle Tom – who all appreciate Rachel for the person she is.
Dulcie however is with her mother: morning, noon and night. Mrs Wintle treats her as an extension of herself – Dulcie, pretty and talented, will be the stage success that she never was herself. She even talks to her in this manner addressing her as “Mum’s Little Leading Lady”.
Dulcie does not go to school and has no friends – in fact the other Wonders hate her and make fun of her even though she is unaware of this. She imitates her mother’s patronising manner towards the Wonders, and has no insight into how she comes across.
The adults in Dulcie’s life seem completely unaware of the damage that her mother is inflicting upon her. Pursey and Mrs Storm tolerate her (preferring Rachel and Hilary), the dancing staff refer to her as “Mrs W’s Little Horror”. Her father Tom has no connection with her at all. Rachel, his niece, spends hours in his studio or out sketching with him; he suggests a way to do her hair and designs clothes for her. But we see no interaction between him and his daughter, he has handed her over to her mother and washed his hands of her.
Noel Streatfeild seems to have little sympathy for Dulcie, in effect blaming her for her self-centredness and conceit. We are meant to rejoice at her downfall – and because it is actually her mother’s downfall, we do. Although the end of the book hints that she will have a glowing future in musical comedy productions, it seems likely that she is too damaged by her mother’s bullying to be able to have any meaningful relationships or decide for herself who she wants to be.
Although extreme, this situation comes across as believable. This is how narcissistic bullies treat people. Dulcie, the victim, is isolated and unaware. She has no one to speak up for her…
Synopsis here: Wintle’s Wonders by Noel Streatfeild